True

true

true

FROM THE THREAD
You're on fire.
I'm no biology expert so what happens when the tree dies? Doesn't it degrade the CO2 it captured and converted to organic matter back into simple products such as methane and CO2 once again?
And every winter when it drops its leaves. It only stores carbon while it’s growing.
The top photo has an energy efficiency of converting photons to MJ of chemical energy of only 0.1 %. Photosynthesis is painfully slow. The bottom photo may actually save the world. GREEN LIES MATTER
If you know, that if there is more CO2 we have more growing...humans, tree's , animals, plants...than you know why they try to get ridd of CO2...it suits them.
The first one benefits humanity. The second one benefits cronies.
Guess which one the government will fund?
Tom Kirkman interesting comment for a fossil lobbyist.
🇺🇦 we can keep this simple. Tom Kirkman is correct, and you are wrong. Oil and natural gas are renwable resources. Trees do a better job with carbons. We need more trees than some made up idea for a money grab. Wind turbines kill birds too. Wind and solar farm development kill thousands of creatures and habitats, also. Solar is very inefficient. Stripping the earths soil of minerals and metals for batteries IS NOT RENEWABLE! Turbine blades and solar panels are next to impossible to recycle efficiently. And lastly, nice Ukraine flag. Have you sent them any money lately, or is that just our corrupt president stealing from us to pay off his debts?
Good luck.
So true,
Been fine for millions of years.....
The % of CO2 in the air is .04% ........wrap your head around that........Z
Got thst right
Simple, plant more trees and ground the globe-trotting eco-grifters.
I had one post here a few months ago with exactly the same message - In my hometown region in Astrakhan Biosphere Reserve (https://en.unesco.org/biosphere/eu-na/astrakhan) we planted hundreds of willow trees the project having the carbon capture efficiency much higher than any industrial CCUS facility not to mention the financial cost efficiency.
And Bill Gates is planning to cut down 75 Million trees to reduce their Carbon footprint?!
God had the best solution. Urban sprawl taking up real estate for generations without re-forestation is our own fault as humans
By that logic I want to do the math:
40 trees removes about a ton of CO2 per year.
Canada produces 545M tons of CO2 per year = planting 22 billion trees. Space required which we do have: 50K sqkm of trees at 25sq ft per tree.
Then, after planting the 22b trees you will have to plant an additional 1B per year to keep up with tree death. @ about .40c all in for a tree to be planted cost would be about 8.8B + 400M per year.. Not bad really.
If Canada could get 18K tree planters or some cool machine AI robotic planters for a season (120days) we could get it done and be carbon (-) in about 15 years.
Wouldn't mind that at all.
Much easier than cutting emissions… and spare a thought for the poor fossil fuel companies, their billions in profits, and hostile foreign producers who love you so much, they’d never use your money to fund terrorists, militants, or wars.
Don't discount the largest surface portion of the planet. Oceans. It's not all about land.
Trees emit water vapor, a potent greenhouse gas. This traps more heat than the CO2 they hold would have.
There’s your first problem Bill, you’re getting your information from morons, conspiracy theory wackos and fossil fuel backed propagandists. There’s good reason they’re getting banned for spreading misinformation.
Good luck, and don’t forget your tinfoil hat!
Doug Hartmann Did you even read the article saying that our current CO2 concentration is close to trapping all the CO2 that it can trap and that adding more won't trap much more heat?
Amen. And the first can be planted by the millions world wide. And all it takes is "seed capital" :)
Except the top one releases the O2 to the air for humans and other animals to breathe, while the bottom puts it underground, under the presumption that we won't one day suffocate.
This can’t be real…
This is an Industrial Hemp Field that sequesters 25% more CO2 than a stand of trees on equivalent acreage. It is beneficial to the atmosphere, does not require tons of water and insect control, it has limited THC or the psychoactive component of marijuana, it is a food source, a source for rope, clothing, soaps, hempcrete, hempwood and more. It is a crop that sustained life for thousands of years until it was undercut in the late 1800s then politically shelved in 1931 when it was declared a schedule 1 drug under federal law although that has begun to change since 2018.
https://cdn.britannica.com/89/211689-004-F2BBE76E/hemp-plantation.jpg?s=1500x700&q=85
people are getting so stupid that it's better not to say anything else because it will only make you sick
LinkedIn AI
Yes just see and understand..with NO comments...
I'd like to point out that ordinary trees are solar energy collectors and storage devices, which additionally create significant levels of surface temperature cooling. They can eventually be used to beneficially heat for human survival via space heating and cooking. You know, it's almost like somebody designed this stuff.
But as long as someone can profit off of it, it will become a part of our oil and gas Industry. I am not against carbon capture even though I have reservations about the severity of Man Made climate change. If we can harness CO2 then let’s do it. Just because the libs push it doesn’t mean we can’t use it to our advantage🤷♂️
it isn’t climate change, it is climate charge on most people that can’t afford it. Are we paying for all the mismanaged governments?
Our planet as increased in temperature every year since the ice age, carbon dioxide has given us a green planet. Whatever we decide to do, nature will take its course. ( if you leave a house empty for a few years, a tree will or other natural growths will appear ) trust nature it is bigger than any human.
Indeed and absolutely completely unnecessary - a delusion based on a willful revision of the temperature data. Carbon dioxide is not a pollutant but essential to life on Earth
very rough estimates but one million square miles of forest represents over 1 trillion tons of CO2 and absorbs 60-70 bullion tons of CO2 annually
No it's just green washing. And can be effective if CO2 pumped into the subsurface is used for oil recovery, but you won't hear the companies doing this mentioning the oil part..
Without China and India, all attempts at reducing carbon emissions are futile, and most are corporate grifters selling bogus solutions to get rich off of government subsidies.
Absolutely
only during daytime/sunshine, when the tree has leaves and when it is not tooo hot.
We need to plant more trees…when you see land clear-cut for new houses, and all that concrete poured…that is one of the biggest problems we have.
Trees take in CO2, the concrete blocks water from being absorbed, we end up with excessive water run off, flash floods etc…
In my opinion, when a tree is removed to make way for construction, that tree needs to be replaced by the contractor.
Instead of investing all of this money in wild schemes, the government should be planting more trees and managing the nations forest including removal of dead trees and excess undergrowth.
This one is pure gold: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=MSZgoFyuHC8
The masses will believe literally anything government funded "experts" on TV tell them. We know that to be a fact, since the "pandemic". They have been hypnotised to believe nonsense and feel self-righteous defending their programming.
I wish we planted more and stop cutting down most of the trees and plants we have.
Without CO2 we will lack oxygen. Crazy buying in this idea.
That’s the funniest thing I’ve read all month. Nice.
Love this!
You nailed it.
👍
Just try to convince Washington
😂😂😂😂
Trees aren't the only excellent carbon capture and storage plant. An acre of hemp for fiber stores 4X the amount of carbon per acre each year (400Tons per acre!). Anyone growing hemp should sign up to sell their carbon credits if they aren't already doing so. This can be huge if your acreage is of any size. Who can't use the extra income stream at no cost to the farmer. Check out this link for more information:
https://hempcarbonstandard.com/signup/b73341e721
Isn't the tree more of a Carbon Capture and Utilization process?
so do not distrube the earth with big machines. and do not cut the trees with big machines. and oh yes if you have wood do not burn it.
Clue probably in the word 'plant'...
Then there's the added bonus of the oxygen trees produce!
The upper option
The Plants are created by Allah the most grecious most merciful who created everything for the benefit of human for free and without any side hazarsous products or effects.
While the second option which is psychopathic delusion is made by Money hunters , without any consideration , only money
If every person on earth planted a tree this year it would solve the problem.
Grow more trees problem solved
Randal Williams I actually do all the time. True story I also grow my own food 👏👏👏👏
Tom,
CCS is it not a “psychopathic delusion”. but with real investment by he major oil companies. There are not enough trees to capture all the excess CO2 of the industrialized world. The best sequestration is 500 m and deeper in the oceans, where CO2 turns into a slush, heavier than water.
Yup… “The very gods struggle in vain against stupidity” Schiller
Cost in the millions.
CCS 'might' work for specific rock formations (porous), but its clearly not a great solution to spend an immense amount of energy and resources to build the plant and a lot of energy to force a limited portion of emitted CO2 underground.
Current plans worldwide are to keep going, and to burn even more energy while doing so, in our race to mass produce wind and solar farms which so far are complementing rather than replacing our current means of production.
We are unable to slow down and things will get worst before they start getting better.
Malinvestments aiming to endebt and enslave us. What a sham. We should put an end to the central banks.
Seems like it would create more pollution than it would prevent.
Only difference is, someone is making money on the psychopathic version.
- and trying desperately to control others.
👏👏👏 no capex/opex/vc money required. Lets just stop burning the storage unit and find other alternatives to defossilization.
I wish more people truly understood this.
Carbon Capture
Why is direct air capture (DAC) of CO2 a dangerous distraction?
https://www.linkedin.com/feed/update/urn:li:activity:6935548080586956800/
Direct Air Capture Technology, Not so Fast! Just Have a Think
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jM7IZM04XG4
Carbon Dioxide Removal. A BIG loophole for business
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=DGoOmUIYVSo
Honest Government Ad | Carbon Capture & Storage
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=MSZgoFyuHC8
'The amount of energy required by direct air carbon capture proves it is an exercise in futility'
https://www.rechargenews.com/energy-transition/the-amount-of-energy-required-by-direct-air-carbon-capture-proves-it-is-an-exercise-in-futility/2-1-1067588
Pure gold Tom Kirkman
Thanks Wilfred (Bill) Allen
Lol, the truth hurts
Simply man trying to play God.
Douglas H. Or simply humans trying to undo our own harms
There is a school of thought that CO2 levels are dangerously low. Not sure lowering CO2 isn't the real harm. We know for a fact that plants do better with more CO2 which is why greenhouse companies pump CO2 into their growing rooms with great success.
The people that say CO2 is causing harm to the planet has been wrong 100% of the time on all of their predictions for the last 50 years.
Right!
False. There is no Environmental Apocalypse. Read Michael Schellenberger's "Apocalypse Never", or Alex Epstein's Fossil Future.
Not responsibly developing our oil and gas resources will put billions of people into energy poverty - and food poverty worldwide. It is immoral to not develop cheap, safe, clean energy for humanity. Shame on you.
no money to be made off corruption without fear mongering “disasters”……….
Where is the place for the cows to process thier farts? (LOL)
Trees only store it till they die though
Conclusion...plant more trees:)
Tom, Both of them are needed. While your idea is truly beneficial with LNG Plants CO2 emissions in places like Indonesia and Malaysia where forests are abundant just across the fence from the plants, it is not the case in places like Qatar or Australia or even Louisiana
More tree planting!! Yes,yes.
In spite of the hyperbole I’d say both would help.
Can’t argue with fact
Cheaper to plant a tree. But you can't get rich planting a tree can you?
They study for years and then such bullshit comes out.
Well you cant argue with that
The level of CO2 is very low. Some think it is in the 60% but it is .04%
And historically low in geological time it seems.
And yet it's now high enough to wreck our entire planet's ecosystems. Enough with the "ha ha it's nothing", maybe it was different in the Jurassic but we're nothing like the dinosaurs as well.
Brilliant visualization 👏
true, however what is its yield/performance? per year, year on year (deciduous tree)... etc
Yes but there is still a fundamental difference: the object above doesn't generate any business at all!
db
Dan Miller
Funny how green those trees are along the highways here in the PNW!
Converting inorganic carbon into organic.... As just offsetting won't help... Just what I think..!!
Oui et non.
Si l'équipement de capture du co2 est situé au plus près de la source, il est plutôt efficace.
Le but étant de capturer le co2 avant qu'il ne soit relâché dans l'atmosphère.
👏👏👏👏
Let’s also focus on #grasslands.
There is no money in planting trees.
Life's irony... once upon a time (maybe 20 years ago), industrialists/conservatives would mock environmentalists/liberals with the term "tree hugger". Nowadays, the environmentalists seek an industrial solution to what a tree already does while the industrialist points out the miracle of what a tree does to avoid building a new industry. Not passing judgment on either trees or carbon capture (with this post)... just find the role reversal humorous.
I am a tree hugger. Happy to be
I agree. Stop cutting down forests and jungles and start planting trees.
It amazes me why such intelligent people go along with this garbage and actually invest the time and effort!
The reason of course is $$$$$$$$$. Pure and simple.
Nice meme. Got any data?
One is natural
The other needs electrical power , plant operatives and creates waste.
We have 318 billion trees in Canada. Each one absorbs approximately 23 kg CO2/ year. Do the math ladies and gentlemen, do the math!
Hallelujah! Yes! Oui! Si! "The Light!", said the lil' tree that could synthesize food from light and Carbon Dioxide 😋
We will all be drinking carbonated water soon enough!
The lamestream media loves this delusion...
Plants, have BEEN doing this! Maybe we should look to Ecology's intellligence to better understand solutions to remediate our "problems".
🌞
I love this! Nature wins
The sad fact about the whole carbon capture is that it’s a way to subsidize Wall Street through the oil and gas industry. Back in 2007, I read an article about how the industry needed new CO2 plants for CO2 injection and stimulation in wells. The problem was that CO2 was a cheap commodity and people were not building new plants. Which industry was it that became hero like and volunteered to help with the storage aspect of this big lie?
I love the oil and gas industry, that’s why I’m running for Railroad Commission of Texas. However, I don’t like or support the manipulation of the industry by Wall Street and career politicians.
it's a plan to do as nature does.
The problem is the concept of Truth has been killed by those who only believe in their truth. Reason: dead. Logic: dead. Objective facts: dead. In today’s West, truth is in they eye of the beholder.
Well played and well said 😂🤣👍
Every highway median and shoulders should be heavily vegetated. Why the heck are they faux golf courses, requiring constant maintenance?
Absolutely grow more trees
Stan R. What dumb it down to dig a hole with a shovel. Lol 😂
Forest Volatile Organic Compounds and Their Effects on Human Health: A State-of-the-Art Review
And the tree gives us oxygen to breathe and shade from the sun, and will eventually give us timber to use...
As well as just being kind of beautiful 😍
Plant trees. Do not expect any medals from the woke mentally disabled persons.
Missing trees in USA cause of tornados trail every year!
How and when did common sense become so un-common?
C’est devenu flagrant maintenant tout d’un coup .
There is no money in it.
Yep.
It is alternately known as grift, manipulation, non productive cronyism, aaaaaand yes, carbon fascism.
https://wethepeoplealaska.substack.com/p/carbon-fascism-where-it-came-from
Yes!
Fantastic use of tax payers money 😂, the tree is for free!
Plant a tree and stop invading sporting events and destroying works of art.
Can’t fool Mother Nature…..
grow more trees!!!
Tom Kirkman - Your new title is FANTASTIC
Thanks Stuart Turley
Exactly. Savesoil.org
The first image, it works.
The 2nd image, can scam money from tax payers. Brilliant.
This is very true. Tom Kirkman
Nothing delusional about building fake plants that do nothing but mitigate fear for the gullible and made to look like new trillions of tax dollars are "at work".
In Germany we're even more clever. We cut down forests/trees to build wind turbines to save CO2 emissions. 🤙🤣
Haha...indeed
The tree costs a few dollars to plant. The man made plant costs millions if not billions. But because the "capture and storage" plant supports the narrative and corruption of the CO2 scam, corrupt politicians will chose that option instead.
Great post
Oil majors are building all sorts of infrastructure to "support" the carbon capture business..
Sort of to offset the carbon taxes that are in place.
Imagine, moving carbon on land and sea via expensive infra and then "injecting" them into the ground. I wonder how they got the governments to approve the EIA and the basis of such EIA.
Its my opinion that this entire supply chain is ludicrous.
That's why WV is carbon neutral
This is what happens when people either don’t understand the science of the natural world, or are trying to scam taxpayers for a buck.
💯 %
If all else fails revert back to God’s creation!
I love this...
That's a great meme - love it!
Alienated technologies & sciences.
Amen.
100%
Are we are looping back again to the Global Cooling Climate Crisis…Are we are looping back again to the Global Cooling Climate Crisis ? . Reposted from Christian LeuchtenbergThe world should be preparing for a real Climate…Read post →
Dyslexic spamDyslexic spam .Read post →
My website went live today, mixing my usual absurd surreal silliness with…My website went live today, mixing my usual absurd surreal silliness with practical realities 😁 https://tom-kirkman.com/ .Read post →Enjoyed that?
Get the next one.
New posts on energy, projects and Weekend Science — straight to your inbox, without the algorithm.