Impressed by positive wordsmithing that dodges the censors

I’m impressed by the wordsmithing of positive viewpoints that gently nudge thinking without provoking the ire of censors.

Well done. Seriously. Easier said than done.

Reposted from Ziad K Abdelnour

They say “People are not good enough and must be restrained by government”

What makes someone a good person? Is it a willingness to obey rules, or is it something else?

How a person answers these questions will reveal a lot about his or her understanding of what the government is and what it should do.

Another way to think of this is to consider why we have laws in the first place.

Some people believe that people are not good and must be forced by the government to do the right thing. Otherwise, they think, we’d be little more than animals who live by the law of the jungle where only the strongest survive.

But is this really the only way that there can be peace and order in a society?

All dealings between human beings can be placed in one of two categories— voluntary cooperation or coercion. In other words, we can either use persuasion or force to get our way.

This is true whether we’re talking about getting a child to eat her broccoli or getting an adult to purchase a particular item. Persuasion takes more effort because we need to convince the other person to voluntarily do what they are being asked to do.

Force is simply a matter of telling someone to do something or be punished.

But is a person who is being forced to do something, even if it’s supposed to be good for them, really acting like a good person? Or are they simply doing whatever it takes to avoid punishment?

For a person to be good, he or she must be able to freely choose to do good things. This means that this person must also be able to choose not to do those good things.

This is a very frightening thought for some people.

They worry that if it weren’t for laws telling us exactly what we can and cannot do, others would steal, lie, and harm one another in order to get what they wanted. But laws alone are not enough to make us good people.

Those who believe that people are not good and must be restrained or forced by the government to do what they consider the right thing believe that, with enough laws, they can make people be good—or at least their version of what’s good.

In reality, the best they can do is make people obedient to their rules. And obedience is not the same thing as being a good person.

The line between good and bad is found in our hearts. Each of us can choose to act on our best or worst desires. When we freely choose to reject actions that would harm another or infringe on his or her natural rights, we are truly being good.

When we do something because we fear the threat of force and punishment being used against us if we don’t, we’re simply being obedient.

See the difference?

Government can punish actions that have harmed others and can help ensure that justice is done. But it cannot make us good people by forcing us to do what someone else considers to be the right thing.

*Credit: The Libertas Institute #people #law #society

FROM THE THREAD

Comments 2

  1. vincent sullivan
  2. terry sexton

    This is so right, and yes our hearts are the key in making good decisions for others and ourselves

Leave a comment

Your email address will not be published. Comments are checked before they appear.

Keep reading

Enjoyed that?
Get the next one.

New posts on energy, projects and Weekend Science — straight to your inbox, without the algorithm.