Clean electrification of everything is a rainbow pipe dream

The “clean electrification” of everything in the U.S. is not possible.

It is a rainbow pipe dream, being force fed by federal government zealots onto a gullible populace who mostly seem to believe the climate panic armageddon Chicken Little bullpoop.

Doubling the U.S. electrical grid is a task that is currently not possible, for reasons such as:

– supply chain constraints,
– materials constraints (copper for example),
– electrical transformers constraints,
– cost (with inflation already out of control),
– insufficient experienced manpower to massively out build the electrical grid infrastucture,
– land constraints,
– government permitting constraints,
… the list goes on.

Even this article, which *totally* buys into the climate scaremongering, admits there are “major hurdles” to overcome in the impossible quest to convert from hydrocarbons and nuclear to a “clean electrification” of everything.

Side note, the phrase “clean electrification” is my own wry term for this hopeless and exceedingly expensive agenda.

Yes, the U.S. electrical grid is already strained and bursting at the seams.

Yes, the U.S. electrical grid needs to be upgraded and modernized.

But *doubling* the grid is simply not possible at the present time.

=======================

“In order to keep up with the expansion of renewable energy production capacity, the United States will have to more than double the current size of the electric grid.

… Meeting global climate goals requires a rapid and massive expansion of renewable energy production capacity.

< < < caution: panic trigger warning > > >
< < < everybody PANIC HARDER ! > > >

● The urgency of this imperative is difficult to overstate; indeed, the United Nations has announced a code red for humanity.

Building sufficient wind and solar farms to power the clean energy transition will require overcoming three major hurdles:

– finding enough land at an affordable price,

– building up the power grid to support the influx of electricity, and

– fixing the archaic and inefficient permitting process that governs these processes.

… The grid doesn’t just need to be expanded, it also needs to be improved.

The United States power grid is an aging and fractured system that will require major updates to bring it into the modern era and to prepare it for a massive influx of variable energy that it wasn’t designed to handle.

… It’s great that wind and solar capacity are being added at a record-breaking rate, but it’s all a waste if, once completed, there’s no permit allowing them to plug into the grid – or if there’s no grid at all.”

Open link ↗

FROM THE THREAD

Comments 24

  1. Sébastien Kahn

    Electric cars has been described as pipe dream until fairly recently

  2. Dr. Michael Vail PhD. FCSI

    Is there enough copper in the whole world to realise and action this green wet-dream ?

  3. Marty Bidusreplying to Michael Vail

    F Fin FCPA we become enormously vulnerable by relying on just green electric power (and we are only 13% of the way there, ie, from wind and solar). The grid becomes a huge target for our enemies. Secondly, we only recycle 10% of wind towers and solar panels, so ignoring the landfill and toxicity impacts. Thirdly, we don’t have the rare metal resources again making us extraordinarily vulnerable to foreign players especially China. Technology will not overcome those issues. Continue to ignore. We already know we will be gaslit about the real economic and social costs of “green” energy.

  4. Dr. Michael Vail PhD. FCSI

    Marty, but until the decision-makers wake-up, there’s a lot of people making a lot of money on the alternative. We need Nuclear ☢️ for cheap energy power generation

  5. Keith Hermann

    What I fail to read here is any basic assumptions and statistics derived therefrom. Here are some starting assumptions of Cu requirements. This assumes a breakdown of 25% onshore and offshore wind (combined), 30% solar, 15% hydro and nuclear, 10% geothermal, and 5% bioenergy, with a 7-day buffer for storage.

    Onshore wind: 36.8 million tonnes of copper
    Offshore wind: 50.1 million tonnes of copper
    Solar power: 150.7 million tonnes of copper
    Hydroelectric: 54.7 million tonnes of copper
    Nuclear: 3.02 million tonnes of copper
    Geothermal: 11.4 million tonnes of copper
    Bioenergy: 1.83 million tonnes of copper
    Storage: 923.7 million tonnes of copper

    1.23 billion tonnes of Cu with current reserves standing at ~800 million tonnes.

    But we can just find more (see image)?

    But we can just swap out copper with Aluminum? Sure, we could, except conductivity matters, especially for batteries (rate capacity), which is where most of it is going as current collectors. While Na-ion batteries COULD use Al in place of Cu, this will significantly increase Al requirements and lower rate capacity. Something like 2-3 billion tonnes. Also, the actual storage requirement will be higher and this doesn't include EVs

Leave a comment

Your email address will not be published. Comments are checked before they appear.

Keep reading

Enjoyed that?
Get the next one.

New posts on energy, projects and Weekend Science — straight to your inbox, without the algorithm.