Post

FROM THE THREAD

Comments 35

  1. Nathan Cairns

    Robert (Bob) J. Iverach, K.C., ICD.D you are obviously an educated person but you have clearly never worked in or understand manufacturing.
    You are not alone, there is a huge percentage of the population that has zero knowledge of manufacturing in general, nevermind high complexity, large scale industrial manufacturing.
    The fact is, it would take decades for Canadian industry the build the capacity to even consider manufacturing these modules and an equal amount of time to build the skilled workforce and procedures required to be able the compete with legacy builders.
    I suspect Canadian taxpayers are not interested in writing that blank cheque.

  2. Mike Astonreplying to Nathan Cairns

    I do and our entire strapping and wire production has been eliminated by China and finished off by tariffs and policy.

    https://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/hamilton/wire-drawing-activities-close-1.7558193

  3. Luciano Piciacchia

    Robert (Bob): time to change your profile and use an alias. This one has lost all credibility.

  4. Mike Astonreplying to Luciano Piciacchia

    which fact is wrong?

    Please inform the people from the Arcelor wire plant that lost their jobs last summer

    https://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/hamilton/wire-drawing-activities-close-1.7558193

  5. Marc Farrell

    Bob, you’ve pressed the five-alarm fire bell again. At some point we may have to remove the batteries.

    Yes, Canada has real competitiveness challenges in steel and shipbuilding. But your list turns every example into evidence of collapse while leaving out the context.

    LNG Canada used overseas-fabricated modules, but the project also generated billions of dollars in Canadian and B.C. contracts. The new B.C. Ferries vessels are being built in China because no Canadian shipyard submitted a bid. And on Chinese steel dumping, Canada has already imposed trade-remedy measures and surtaxes.

    So by all means argue for more Canadian steel, fabrication and shipbuilding capacity. I do too. But “some components came from China, therefore the Canadian steel industry is collapsing because of government policy” is far too simplistic.

Leave a comment

Your email address will not be published. Comments are checked before they appear.

Keep reading

Enjoyed that?
Get the next one.

New posts on energy, projects and Weekend Science — straight to your inbox, without the algorithm.