Post



FROM THE THREAD
Robert (Bob) J. Iverach, K.C., ICD.D you are obviously an educated person but you have clearly never worked in or understand manufacturing.
You are not alone, there is a huge percentage of the population that has zero knowledge of manufacturing in general, nevermind high complexity, large scale industrial manufacturing.
The fact is, it would take decades for Canadian industry the build the capacity to even consider manufacturing these modules and an equal amount of time to build the skilled workforce and procedures required to be able the compete with legacy builders.
I suspect Canadian taxpayers are not interested in writing that blank cheque.
I do and our entire strapping and wire production has been eliminated by China and finished off by tariffs and policy.
https://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/hamilton/wire-drawing-activities-close-1.7558193
Robert (Bob): time to change your profile and use an alias. This one has lost all credibility.
which fact is wrong?
Please inform the people from the Arcelor wire plant that lost their jobs last summer
https://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/hamilton/wire-drawing-activities-close-1.7558193
Bob, you’ve pressed the five-alarm fire bell again. At some point we may have to remove the batteries.
Yes, Canada has real competitiveness challenges in steel and shipbuilding. But your list turns every example into evidence of collapse while leaving out the context.
LNG Canada used overseas-fabricated modules, but the project also generated billions of dollars in Canadian and B.C. contracts. The new B.C. Ferries vessels are being built in China because no Canadian shipyard submitted a bid. And on Chinese steel dumping, Canada has already imposed trade-remedy measures and surtaxes.
So by all means argue for more Canadian steel, fabrication and shipbuilding capacity. I do too. But “some components came from China, therefore the Canadian steel industry is collapsing because of government policy” is far too simplistic.
everything is imported from China. Sick economy, sick politics, sick...
Do you honestly believe that Mark Carney campaigned on increasing taxes on the domestic steel industry. That simply is mistaken.
“Mark Carney campaigned on increasing taxes on our steel industry." I asked Microsoft Copilot to fact check this statement because it seemed distinctly unlikely that he would do this given the facts surrounding this industry and actually he did not.
”... The sources show: Carney did introduce or maintain tariffs and surtaxes on steel imports (especially U.S. steel during the trade war). Carney also announced new measures to protect Canadian steel, including reduced import quotas and new global tariffs on steel derivatives. These are trade measures, not domestic taxes on Canadian steel producers. Conclusion: Carney’s policies increased tariffs on imported steel, not taxes on Canadian steel producers."
Your objective is obviously not to provide a balanced picture of the pluses and minuses of Carney's policy. It is a hodgepodge of criticisms thrown together regardless of any information to the contrary or even any common sense.
There is a levy on the carbon emissions from smelting. The tax per tonne is scheduled to increase year by year.
This is a major concern for Canadians and the USA who will not allow this violation of USMCA with transhipments
The collapse happened quite some time ago. Now that you have some significant demand you've just exposed it. Not just a Canada situation.
Exactly. Liberal supporters defending this approach have their heads buried in the sand, losing domestic industrial capacity is a strategic risk, not just an accounting exercise. Canada cannot keep celebrating overseas procurement while expecting Canadian steelworkers to survive on patriotic speeches. Beijing gets the orders; Canadians get lectures about competitiveness. Where is the accountability for the decision-makers who call this economic leadership? A cheaper contract means precious little when the long-term price is dependence on our enemy.
This dumping is why the US is tariffing our steel exports.
This is a list of things that all of the Shipyard industry in Canada East coast and West coast, has consistently for the last forty+ years resisted expanding into.
Our shipyards choose not to expand capability and capacity to even hold on to things like Ferry construction, and have never even considered expanding into the type of yard required for this modern module construction.
Also, and understandably as a consequence of never developing the yard strength, our steel industry has not chosen to focus on the type of steel production such heavy industry construction requires.
We live in a country that protects freedom and free market capitalism, we have no mechanism to "order BC Ferries to buy from SeaSpan, and insist that SeaSpan shall be that kind of yard no matter what their own business plan was/is"
To order these module built in Canadian Yards would first require building the yards and developing the skill set, and again, we are not the kind of country where the government is allowed to order business about.
It didn't make sense to our Shipyards to go in this direction according to their own managerial judgement, and likewise cold rolling sheet steel into culverts was the business that Stelco's business model supported.
Don't say also Canada. Say Also Liberal voters.
Do you care where it comes from ,
I am puzzled?
You are upset that Canadian corporations and Canadian pension funds are investing in Canadian infrastructure projects
Chad M. Chad, disagreeing with you about one procurement decision is not “hating Canada.” That kind of personal accusation avoids the actual issue.
I agree that Canadian jobs, quality and strategic capacity matter. But we also have to deal with the facts of each case. In B.C. Ferries, Canadian yards did not submit a bid. With LNG Canada, overseas fabrication was part of a much larger project that still generated substantial Canadian employment and contracts.With LNG there was no steel manufacturers capable of making the turbines.
The sensible debate is how Canada builds more competitive domestic capacity so Canadian firms can win more of this work in the future—not whether anyone who acknowledges global supply chains somehow hates Canada.
Where would Canada build out LNG Process Modules or BC Ferries? Seaspan is fully booked up. If Canada wants to develop a second large shipyard in BC, that would at least open the door.
We can keep our steel industry busy supplying Canada with steel, but, Mr Trump has caused all this change to need to happen quickly. It needs a few years to settle and change the supply directions for everything.
To expect things to change direction on a dime is ridiculous.
Dan Swanson I gather those X posts and snide video clips are from people connected with industry or finance and have a clue what they are talking about as opposed to the substack link you attached that looks like its straight out of a Liberal chatroom
My link was straight from your "friends" at the EU, those "middle powers" that are crumbling internally and grateful for the olive branch the US has offered. Take Note of China Shock 2.0 and get in line. Must be Trump right?
https://www.cer.eu/publications/archive/policy-brief/2026/china-shock-20-cost-germanys-complacency
Mike Aston I was referring to POTUS, but you go guy.
We have imported fabricated steel and pipe from China and India since 2012.
It wasn't right then, and it's not right now.
I remember in the 2000's when Chinese steel started surfacing and being promoted to the O&G fab industry, and the push back was immediate and loud. Apparently, Ottawa has more say than industry or its workers.
Bob, you missed one:
Canadian federal government made in China
🫵Who does the Carney government serve … it wouldn’t/couldn’t be China could it 🫣
Spot on.
Brookfield heavily invested in China
Carney also said how much steel are we going to use!! Thats knowing the square root of F all in industry and just being a bean counter his whole life!!
What no one even question's with all this is there has been many instances the the MTRs(which is material test reports or records) that come from certain countries are fudged and what happens if catastrophic events start to happen....in our country? Are they held responsible for loss of life, damages, etc, etc?
Calling Canadian steel "uncompetitive" is a fundamental category error.
Our mills and modular yards aren't losing on engineering, metallurgical quality, or shop-floor productivity. They are being undercut by state-subsidized offshore yards burning dirty power with zero carbon accountability, while Canadian procurement boards hand out contracts with zero domestic content mandates.
The US protects industrial sovereignty with Buy America and the Jones Act. Canada awards public ferry contracts and energy infrastructure to Chinese state shipyards to shave 10% off initial capex, then spends the difference remediating defective welds and structural non-compliance once the steel hits our docks.
This isn't market failure or lack of competitiveness. It is procurement negligence masquerading as fiscal discipline.
After 11 years of DEI Liberal government, nothing good is happening in Canada. The taxpayers are going broke faster than Canadian businesses.
Are we are looping back again to the Global Cooling Climate Crisis…Are we are looping back again to the Global Cooling Climate Crisis ? . Reposted from Christian LeuchtenbergThe world should be preparing for a real Climate…Read post →
Dyslexic spamDyslexic spam .Read post →
My website went live today, mixing my usual absurd surreal silliness with…My website went live today, mixing my usual absurd surreal silliness with practical realities 😁 https://tom-kirkman.com/ .Read post →Enjoyed that?
Get the next one.
New posts on energy, projects and Weekend Science — straight to your inbox, without the algorithm.